Matthew 25:31-46
Ezekiel 34:11-16, 20-24
My sports loyalties are a bit on the soft side, partly because I’ve moved a lot as an adult, partly because I have a love-hate relationship with what Marxists would call the “false consciousness” of professional sports in America, the multi-millionaires playing for multi-billionaire team owners, the families spending more than they can afford to sit in publicly-subsidized stadiums. I mean, can we talk about billionaire welfare? Then there is the cost of the jerseys. Nonetheless, I watch sports. Probably too much if I am being honest.
I’ve lived in New York for more of my adult life than I have lived anywhere else, and when I came back from Europe in the mid-1990’s, I became a Yankees fan, though it was easier to take the 7 train to see the Mets when I lived in Queens. Then I went to school in the Boston-area, and experienced Boston sports fans firsthand. Now, I root for the Yankees, despite their recent record, the Bills, of course, and anyone playing against a Boston-based team. Anyone.
I’m trying to watch more women’s sports, like the WNBA, and the NWSL, the National Women’s Soccer League. If I don’t have a particular loyalty, I might root for the team based in a blue state, though that is not as useful as it was a couple of months ago. And I almost always root for the underdog, Davey rather than Goliath, with an exception for the Bronx Bombers, though they haven’t looked much like Goliath for awhile.
We know that sport can be dangerous, especially Nascar, which I still watch, and American football, gladiators prepared to die for our entertainment. And gladiators sounds right since sport uses the language of war, but it is not actual war. Someone is going to get a paycheck, a name, image, and likeness deal, or a sponsor, even in college athletics and the Olympics. Bodies get damaged, but people rarely die.
People do die, and die in large numbers, when it comes to actual war and terrorism, and the morality of war can be quite complex. There is something called “Just War” theory, upper case “J,” but in the end, it is just war, lower case “j.” Few would argue that the Allied fight against the murderous Axis powers during World War II was objectively evil, even if the conduct of that war merits scrutiny, even if the Allies included the murderous Soviets under Stalin, who changed sides mid-war, and the Colonialist British Empire, which extended the war to preserve its racist regime. Then again, we were not exactly saints.
For many years, I was able to claim the complexity of the situation in Palestine. I could be horrified at the terrorism of the Palestinian Liberation Organization and yet understand the cause itself, the despair and righteous anger of the Nakba that could drive people to such acts. I could be horrified by the conduct of the State of Israel and yet understand the secular reasoning behind Zionism, even if I rejected the religious framing of that movement.
I have long been plugged into the network of United Church of Christ advocates for the Palestinian people, and I have stood in this pulpit and every pulpit where I have served and worked to dismantle the systemic antisemitism that has poisoned much of Christian history.
Of course, the conflict is not just Israeli Jews against Palestinian Muslims. There are other faiths, other ethnic groups, impacted by the conflict, including an ancient Christian community, and holy sites from all three monotheisms. I once imagined, like others, that there must be some solution, likely the Two-State solution, carving up the land and displacing people. Again for many Palestinians. We’ve seen that film before in the partition of India.
Then came October 7, 2023.
I was outraged by the violence against civilians and the hostage taking. Both sides were guilty of crimes against humanity. But Israel’s defensive war became a war of vengeance which became a campaign of genocide.
My core belief has long been that any ethno-state, any state defined as belonging to one race, religion, or ethnicity, was evil. I can no longer make an exception for Israel. Fundamentalism and nationalism are simply evil, in India and Israel and Indiana.
So as I have always done, as I am called to do, I shared with you from this pulpit and in writing my own spiritual struggle with this mess, the murder of children we were watching on the evening news. But some wanted me to take a stand on one side or the other, forcing me to choose between two evil forces and two populations of innocent victims. This was true in the context of my role as an elected Democrat, and especially in the role I held at the time as Steering Committee Chair for the local Interfaith Coalition.
I refused, and still refuse, to ignore the evil on either side. I’m not going to prefer one murderer over another.
More than anything, though, I realized that Senator Chuck Schumer didn’t care how I felt. Chuck Schumer wouldn’t care if I got a thousand signatures from people in the Southern Tier of New York calling for Israel to stop committing war crimes. He wouldn’t care of I got ten thousand signatures. We pay Chuck Schumer’s salary, but Chuck Schumer does not work for us. And his real employers support the genocide.
That doesn’t mean I don’t advocate for justice, as I am doing right now. It doesn’t mean I’ve given up on trying to align my personal life with my values. I do my best to insure that my participation in this corrupt economy is as mindful as possible. But I invest most of my energy where I believe it can be most effective. I start here.
Today, we read the third and final parable in what came to be called Matthew 25. The authors of Matthew base their text on the earlier Gospel According to Mark, as well as a lost text shared with the Gospel According to Luke which we call “Q” for the German word for “source.” But the authors of Matthew have an agenda, making Jesus look like the new Moses. They rearrange the teachings into five great sermons to match the books of the Torah and move the Beatitudes to a mountain rather than on a plain, the location in Luke. The question, then, is not why Jesus taught these three parables together, as that is highly unlikely. If we look at the stories as a sequence, we ask what understanding of the message of Jesus led the authors to arrange the parable in this way.
Even if we lift this particular parable out of context, we have the troubling problem of damning judgment, the contradiction that also troubled us last Sunday as we claimed a God of mercy. But I want to turn instead to the key phrase in the parable, rendered in the Common English Bible “when you have done it for one of the least of these brothers and sisters of mine, you have done it for me.”
Done what? Protested injustice? Led a military resistance? Rode in as a Messiah sent by God as a great general to restore the Kingdom of David? No!
Jesus does not tell us to be a messiah. Jesus does not ask you to save the world.
“I was hungry and you gave me food to eat. I was thirsty and you gave me a drink. I was a stranger and you welcomed me. I was naked and you gave me clothes to wear. I was sick and you took care of me. I was in prison and you visited me.”
Start here. Start with one life.
Jesus did not establish a universal church, despite the over-wrought theology of later Christians. From Capernaum on the north shore of the Sea of Galilee to the Temple in Jerusalem is only 80 miles! Jesus changed the lives around him. They changed lives around them. And so on and so on until here we are, still telling a story that got passed down a couple of generations before landing in uncertain texts, and still he matters, whether you lean into the grandest of claims, that he was a presence of the holy, or the humblest of claims, that he modeled for us a new way to be in this holy world with one another.
Don’t ignore Gaza. Part of my paycheck pays for those damned bombs. And they are damned. The blood of Palestinian children is on my hands whether I like it or not. I can campaign and I can vote. It is clear that the genocide did influence some voters earlier this month, and AIPAC will have a lot less power in January. But don’t let distance and magnitude paralyze you. Start here.
For me, it is housing justice, the issue that motivated my run for Elmira City Council, and while there are plenty of other issues… budgets and city sanitation and politics, so much politics… my goal continues to be that everyone in Elmira be in a safe home.
It might not be housing for you. Maybe it is reading. Indeed, many folks in this congregation are deeply involved in literacy. Maybe it is freedom for a kid to wear a dress if that is what the child wants to wear. Maybe it is poopy baby butt and a journey to Bath to pick up a load… of diapers of course… for the Twin Tiers Baby Bank.
Start here. Collect coats and mittens. Cook a meal that raises money to provide meals to families that might struggle to put food on the table, much less celebrate a holiday.
Well, yeah… and change the world. Or at least the world for one person, one family. For God is a queer kid who can’t imagine living one more day in this house, going to that school. God can’t sleep because of a tooth ache when the choice is the rent, which the landlord just raised again, or a dentist. God is an eight year-old in ICE detention, separated from his family. God is in the pew next to you looking for a safe space.
What you have done… What have you done? Amen.
PRAYERS OF THE PEOPLE concluding with the Lord’s Prayer
This week, many were deeply saddened by the death of Fiona, a hippopotamus at the Cincinnati Zoo. Once upon a time, zoos were little more than entertainment, but today, they play a critical role in saving countless species, while one species, ours, recklessly undermines our planet’s ability to sustain life. Let us pray.
Let us pray.
Holy Mystery we name as God,
the ancients wrote a story
that centered our species,
made us stewards of every living thing,
imagined you in our own image.
It is hubris, of course,
for you might just as well be a hippopotamus
or an aardvark
or a colony of ants.
We pray this morning for zookeepers in mourning,
for biologists in the field and in their labs,
for climate scientists,
for protesters.
We start here,
helping human and non-human.
Jesus lived in an agrarian society
being crushed by greed,
by the corruption of Temple and council,
by the violent demands of empire.
He started where he was,
feeding and healing,
calling attention to Your kin-dom.
We pray as he taught us, saying:
Our Father…
