Holy Contradiction: 15 November 2026

Zephaniah 1:7, 12-18

Matthew 25:14-30

A smart preacher would approach our reading from Matthew through the lens of stewardship broadly defined, our obligation to leave things better than we found them, then lean into the definition of better as we understand it in our Social Gospel tradition, a just world for all where everyone can thrive, reaching their full potential.

And I admit, that is very tempting, but it is also very lazy. I am lazy, just not very lazy.

The passage ends with the claim that those who already have will receive more, while those who have little will lose even that, and it is not at all clear whether this refers to something material, in which case this passage contradicts almost everything else in the gospel, or something spiritual. The latter is possible, as the authors of Matthew spiritualize things that Luke leaves concrete. For example, where Luke’s Beatitudes bless those who are literally hungry, Matthew’s bless those who hunger and thirst for righteousness.

For the record, you cannot make a righteousness sandwich, though for folks of the “Bill and Ted” generation, a sandwich can be righteous… Dude!

Among the disagreeable things in this parable is a seeming endorsement of financial speculation, and you have heard me denounce profit without production many times from this pulpit.

Then there is the very end of the parable, the servant who was afraid of the Master thrown into “outer darkness” where there is “weeping and gnashing of teeth.” Is the take-away from this parable that we are supposed to fear God? Could be. The Bible has more than 130 references to “fear of the Lord,” in almost every case understood as a virtue.

How do we reconcile this fearful and damning god with the god of grace and mercy that forgives the Israelites again and again, that demands that we forgive that we might be forgiven?

This is the second of three parables in what we now know as Matthew 25, remembering that scripture was not divided into chapters and verses until the Renaissance. The first parable is the tale of the Ten Bridesmaids that we read last week, five wise and five foolish, while the third parable is the well known illustration of the sheep and the goats. That parable includes the line I so often quote, “what you have done to the least of these, you have done also unto me.” But even this beloved passage ends with individuals being condemned to eternal punishment, the “goats” of the illustration.

If God is vengeful and punishing, what exactly did we humans do to deserve this eternal damnation? I’m not okay with anyone suffering for eternity, even if I can think of a few names, and entire government agencies actually.

Is it only for our individual sins that merit damnation, as scripture indicates, or are we back to “original sin”? Which, by the way, isn’t really a thing in scripture but has been a thing in Christianity since Saint Augustine, giving us a god that is very petty and remarkably human, a god created in our own image.

Fundamentalists claim that all scripture is the inspired word of God, including these damning texts. They base this claim on Second Peter, which is pseudoepigraphic, written by someone who was not Peter but wanted to co-opt Peter’s authority. Even if the scriptural basis for their claim was not based on a lie, the Christian Testament wasn’t a thing yet, so it has to mean the Jewish Bible with all its contradictions, of which there are plenty.

Scripture is not the word of God. Not the Authorized Version in Jacobin English, not the various and variant codices.

Scripture is like a painting, an attempt to capture a thing, but not the thing itself, at its best, generations of faithful humans listening to the transcendent in their own historic context, pointing to that powerful force we call God. At its worst, it is humans projecting our own existential fear and petty desire onto an authority that rests on circular logic, like that whole Second Peter thing.

That does not mean you can’t encounter the holy in scripture. But the Bible is a spiritual Rorschach test. There is bashing babies against the rocks in divinely ordered genocide, and the Parable of the Good Samaritan, exact opposite messages. Which were you taught as normative? To which will you choose to conform?

Every preacher and teacher who has interpreted the Bible for you has chosen what is important to them. I invite you to engage deeply with scripture and tradition, with the world around us, natural and human, always through the lens of my own spiritual journey, not out of hubris, but out of hope, that what has worked for me might work for you, that the sum of our being in the world will be rendered a good.

Fundamentalists start and end with a book, blind to the role of imperfect humans in that book. If we don’t start with the book, where do we start?

We start with a decision to believe, conscious or unconscious, belief not in some impossible string of propositions like the Virgin Birth and the Holy Trinity, but that there is goodness and mercy and miracle.

This idea that we start with what we know, what we experience, is condemned as “natural theology,” the opposite of divine revelation, but I cannot prove that the mad man is actually hearing God. I can see a ruckus of Blue Jays at my feeder, the frenzied landings and departures. I can listen to Barber’s Adagio, can look at the architecture of a honeycomb and of Antoni Gaudí’s Sagrada Familia. I can see the creativity and self-ordering in nature and the creativity and self-ordering in our own species, whale song and Willie Nelson.

Celts refer to thin places, where the mundane and transcendent seem close together, and they are real, but they can also be cultivated. That is often a useful work of religion, as it is of the arts, as it is of nature. At our best, it is part of what we do in worship, not in order to manipulate, but in order to tune our spiritual dials to the right frequency.

Believing is seeing, but it alone is not enough. Even if you wanted to drink holiness from the firehose of mystery, the world will not let you. The ache in your back will not let you. The NYSEG bill will not let you.

Thriving requires a spiritual practice, even if you don’t call it spirituality but call it instead surfing or glass blowing or your morning walk. Or maybe prayer or zazen. Intention matters because ExxonMobil does not care about your spiritual health, about your thriving. You are only useful to ExxonMobil, their shareholders, the politicians they own, as long as you participate in the petro-trafficking market.

Take a walk in the woods. Get those old watercolors out of the drawer. Listen to the new and joyful album put out by U2 this week, and don’t multi-task! It includes Saint Dolly’s last recording. What can be more spiritual than that?

Finally, and this is so critically important these days when so many live in algorithm and AI hell, community matters, as Jonathan Larson declared in his musical “Rent,” actual reality. We can experience the thin places with others or alone. We can engage in spiritual practice with others or alone. But we become human in community. We did not evolve to be alone. We do not thrive alone, as messy as we violent bipedal primates can be at times.

Alone, we are not part of the living story that stretches back to Abolitionists in Elmira, to rebels eating sausage during Lent in Zurich, to disciples who saw their charismatic leader brutally executed by empire and still believed. Alone, we are not part of the Antifa story that stormed the beaches at Normandy, not part of the story of faithful patriots of color, from Crispus Attucks, the second casualty of our revolution, to Scott Colom, who dared to run for the United States Senate in Mississippi, and won.

We don’t start at a two thousand year old text filled with contradictions and work from there to now. Truth is, despite their claims, neither do the selective literalists of Fundamentalism. We bring our now to scripture. And our now is shaped by belief, by practice, and by community. By what we do here in this building, and what we carry when we are out there in the mission field.

Sometimes we stumble upon passages that resist a positive spin, all judgment and genocide and patriarchy. But the Spirit is there, as that ancient story unfolds, as our story unfolds. That ancient people moved from an idea of god that is like them to an understanding of God who is more, is serendipitous creativity, is self-ordering complexity, is that mysterious X in the equation that we call love. The Word of God lives through the living. Amen.

PRAYERS OF THE PEOPLE concluding with the Lord’s Prayer

This coming Friday will be the Transgender Day of Remembrance. This morning, we especially remember Jonathan McKinsey, a New York Times employee murdered by his elderly in-laws in California on September 26th.

Let us pray.

Mother God,
beyond biological sex
and human constructs of gender,
we pray for those who do not fit
in the box we have made,
particular to this place
and time
and culture.

We also remember that our religious trajectory is filled with journeys,
some more direct than others,
from Ur to the Land of Canaan,
wandering in the desert for decades,
from Galilee to Bethlehem,
spreading the good news along Roman roads.

We pray this morning for travelers,
passengers pulled from the cold and muddy Mississippi,
passengers trapped in airports,
not just sports teams,
but those rushing to a loved one’s bedside.

We pray for the employees,
deck hands and desk agents,
the counter worker at the airport Dunkin’
and the bartender behind the three deep bar.

We pray for the hundreds of FAA employees
laid off by DOGE
to fund tax cuts for billionaires.

Jesus walked the roads of Galilee,
traveled to Jerusalem
where he was murdered
by religion and empire,
executed to protect the powerful.

We pray as he taught us, saying:

Our Father

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *